Chatswood serves the life and health insurance sector in New Zealand with market intelligence, data, and bespoke consulting services. Some of these are provided in conjunction with Quality Product Research Limited - a subsidiary that brings you Quotemonster.
We believe that good decisions are more likely to occur when we have good information about the market environment in which we operate. Intuitive leaps and creative decisions are always required, of course, but the more they are based on a firm foundation of observation, the better they tend to be.
Best product, no. Best solution, yes!
Steve Wright questions what makes the best product in his latest article on Good Returns.
We are in enthusiastic agreement with Steve Wright’s recent article, in which he questions what makes the best product in his latest article on Good Returns. Steve advocates that the FMA and Disputes Resolution Service need to debunk the view of advisers that they sell only the ‘best’ product as rated by independent services.
As a research business, we are happy to debunk the notion that we tell people what to sell, or ‘rank’ products. We go to great pains to point out that this is not our job, we understand that our role is to provide useful information about the meaningful differences between products to enable advisers to have better conversations about suitability. We will never tell you what product to recommend because only financial advisers can give financial advice. To quote directly from a slide from our recent roadshow:
We also highlighted the importance of recognising the financial adviser’s unique role in the process of reconciling objectives with options and choices and limitations to arrive at a good solution, which is nearly always a compromise, unique to the client. That’s the essence of suitability assessment, entirely within the financial adviser’s legally defined role. If you haven’t heard us talk through the leading car purchase example, join us at a training session coming soon!
Like Steve, we believe that the best product is the one that suits the specific clients’ needs – even if it’s not the most generous, or the highest rated. He stresses that advisers must thoroughly understand a client’s individual circumstances, risks, and goals to come up with the most suitable product, then give enough detail that the clients can understand the advice and the products recommended.
What are some examples you’ve come across of products that at first look may not be the ‘best’, but actually have been the best fit for your clients?
If you have missed some of the comments on Steve’s article, we particularly like these:
“Advisers must give financial advice that I'd suitable… suitability has a lot more to do with the client circumstances than stars”
“In short, I don’t believe that we should be looking for who’s the “best.” I believe we should be looking for the “best fit.” And that’s a very different thing!”
“It's a good discussion point, but if you want a more realistic glimpse of what is likely to happen here in the future, speak to those involved in the Australian market about the removal of the 'safe harbour' provision in their financial advice regulation. Not only is it likely that product research into features and benefits likely to become more necessary, not less, but it also seems more and more likely that the actual underwriting terms offered across the entire market will need to be considered.”
More news:
Financial Advice NZ upcoming webinars and workshops - Data Informed Decisions & Demonstrating Suitability of Advice for Private Health Insurance 28 May, Navigating the Complexities of a Blended Family 11 June, Ethics Workshop 12 June, Understanding Portfolio Investment Entities (PIE’s) 25 June, Tackling the Tough Questions 25 June
Apex Advice partners with Pathfinder to expand ethical KiwiSaver investment options
The Co-operative Bank comes top in customer satisfaction survey
MAS announce appointment of new CEO
Jo McCauley has been appointed new Chief Executive Officer of MAS, starting 4 August 2025.
Jo McCauley has been appointed new Chief Executive Officer of MAS, starting 4 August 2025. McCauley is currently CEO of Southern Cross Travel Insurance, and she has a general insurance and consumer finance background, having led marketing, sales and product teams.
MAS Chair Brett Sutton said
“Jo brings a rare combination of leadership experience, commercial insight and strong people skills. We are excited to work with Jo as we build on a strong FY25 result and invest further in technology and service enhancements for our Members”.
More news:
AIA Group’s operating profit after tax reached $6.61 billion for 2024
Arthur J. Gallagher acquires First Capital Financial Services and First Capital Wealth Management
Gail Costa thanks advisers in her farewell message
Financial Advice NZ Special General Meeting 2025 is on 19 May in Auckland
Banking Reform Coalition wants ComCom to prosecute big four banks
AMP are looking for a Senior Application Analyst
IBANZ chief executive Mel Gorham will step down on June 26
BNZ offer relief for customers affected by recent severe weather events
ASB offer tailored emergency relief to customers affected by severe weather
Westpac's net profit after tax for the six months to March 31 was $565 million
Paddy Gower calls for Health Minister to better fund paediatric palliative care
Bigger not necessarily best when it comes to KiwiSaver
Big banks, with their brand recognition and big budgets, have long been an almost default choice for people deciding who to invest their KiwiSaver funds with. That looks like it’s starting to change.
Consumer NZ has taken a look at how KiwiSaver is going. Big banks, with their brand recognition and big budgets, have long been an almost default choice for people deciding who to invest their KiwiSaver funds with. That looks like it’s starting to change. Encouragingly, 29% of new members chose their KiwiSaver scheme independently, and 8% consulted a financial adviser about what their best option would be, though 14% were automatically allocated a default scheme. There is still some reluctance to change providers, with 12% of people feeling it’s too much hassle to change provider, 8% having thought about switching but haven’t gotten around to it and 5% not knowing where to start.
With more than 3.3 million members and more than $111 billion of total funds under management, it’s worth putting in a little effort to see which fund best suits your situation.
While banks in general are big spenders on advertising, ANZ outspends them all. Yet ANZ’s KiwiSaver returns are underwhelming, coming in last (12th) for its management of conservative KiwiSaver funds, 6th (out of 12) for moderate funds, second to last (out of 15) for balanced funds and 10th (out of 12) for growth funds, according to Morningstar’s December 2024 results. Yet ANZ holds the largest share of the KiwiSaver market, with $21.9 billion funds under management.
As of 2021, ANZ and ASB are no longer default KiwiSaver providers, leaving BT Funds (Westpac) and BNZ as the only default big bank providers for new members. It will be interesting to see how this impacts the various banks’ KiwiSaver market share over the next decade or two.
In good news, Consumers NZ’s annual survey on KiwiSaver satisfaction highlights growing satisfaction, with February 2025 results showing 82% were satisfied with their provider.
And what do people most want from their KiwiSaver provider? Good returns with responsible investments came out top (42%), followed by the best returns (37%) and investing responsibly, even if it comes with slightly lower returns (14%)
More news:
Southern Cross Health Society using Patient Feedback to celebrate surgeons
Shaun Phelan is retiring from his role as National Manager of MAS Business Advisory Services
AML Summit 2025 is on 8 - 9 May in Auckland and livestreamed
Fidelity Life financial strength rating reaffirmed
Fidelity Life has had its A- (Excellent) financial strength rating affirmed by AM Best.
Fidelity Life, New Zealand’s largest locally owned life insurer, had its A- (Excellent) financial strength rating affirmed by AM Best. The outlook for the rating is stable, and according to AM Best, reflects Fidelity Life’s ‘very strong’ balance sheet.
Fidelity Life Chief Financial Officer Simon Pennington said
“This A- rating from AM Best is a reassuring endorsement of our business's financial health and stability. As a life insurer, this independent assessment gives advisers confidence in partnering with us, and for customers, it ensures peace of mind in our ability to pay claims.”
More news:
Brendan Boyle starts as Pharmac’s Acting Chief Executive on Monday 31 March
Westpac-McDermott Miller Consumer Confidence Index falls to 89.2 in March
FSC’s FAP round table breakfast with the FMA
Several of our team attended the Financial Services Council’s FAP round table breakfast with the Financial Markets Authority last month.
Quality Product Research are sponsors of the Financial Services Council’s (FSC's) FAP round table breakfast with the Financial Markets Authority (FMA) last month. Several of our team were there, including Aneel Ravji, AdviceTech Lead, Kelly Pulham, National Partnerships Lead, and Russell Hutchinson, Research Director.
The FMA covered how the new regime is working, approaches to enforcement and other initiatives. Attendees were taken through the background and given an overview of the Conduct of Financial Institutions (CoFI) regime. Other topics included observations on remediations, fair conduct programmes and an overview of the CoFI intermediated distribution guide. Russell Hutchinson facilitated a lively Q&A session.
Here's a few snaps from the day. We highly recommend you attend the FSC round tables if you get the chance, they always make for an interesting and engaging start to the day.
Pictured, from the Financial Markets Authority, from left to right: Michael Hewes, Director, Deposit Taking, Insurance and Advice; Anna Jared, Technical Specialist – Deposit Taking, Insurance & Advice; Kyla Bottriell, Senior Adviser, External Relations; and Romil Ghelani, Head of Financial Advice
Russell Hutchinson, Director at Quality Product Research Ltd, facilitates a Q&A session.
Fidelity Life open applications for training programmes
Fidelity Life has opened applications for Advice Masters, Professional Pathways, Practice Manager Masterclass and Career Connect.
Fidelity Life has opened applications for Advice Masters, Professional Pathways, Practice Manager Masterclass and Career Connect.
Applications are open for Advice Masters, Fidelity Life's intensive training and personalised professional development programme designed for experienced business owners in the financial services industry. The programme encompasses a wide range of topics: M&A; capital raising/funding strategies; high performance for business leaders; leading high performing teams; business strategy design and execution; governance; board craft; director skills and sustainability; business efficiency; technology and AI. The 30 available spots are by invitation only – interested people can talk to their business manager or apply here.
Professional Pathways is Fidelity Life's customisable extended training and development programme designed for motivated advisers, who are dedicated to growth and achieving their business goals. Over a 9-month period the programme will take participants through key topics – developing their business; advice and planning; business sales and growth; business efficiency. The programme consists of skills based workshops, self-paced learning through courses, resources and quizzes, online webinars and interactive online workshops.
Practice Manager Masterclass are targeted at admin staff and will help to improve workflow and productivity.
Career Connect is Fidelity Life's comprehensive education and skills programme designed to develop the next generation of financial advisers. Career Connect equips participants with relevant qualifications, practical skills and knowledge, and industry connections. The 2025 intake will commence in May and will run for 6 months. Applicants will be invited for an interview and the fee for the programme is approximately $1650.
More news:
Financial Advice NZ webinar 'Shaping the future of financial advice' 11 December
Unimed offer customers My Food Bag discounts
Russell Hutchinson reviews a game to teach financial literacy
Sam Friggens appointed general manager climate transition at ASB
Health NZ proposing to lay off 1500 staff in restructure proposal
Partners Life release claims statistics
Partners Life have released historical and current claims statistics.
Some interesting statistics have been released by Partners Life around claims. Since Partners Life launched in 2011:
Partners Life have paid out more than 70,000 claims worth more than $1.25 billion.
Their biggest monthly disability claim paid was for $1,617,691
The longest running claim paid for monthly disability cover was 4,068 days and the average claim length was 293 days
Partners Life paid 13,379 monthly disability cover claims totalling $225,954,755
Their biggest life cover claim paid was for $2,964,706
Partners Life paid 1422 life cover claims totalling $334,281,111
Partners Life paid 51,827 private medical cover claims totalling $353,468,683
Their biggest private medical cover claim paid was for $982,800
Partners Life paid 3,948 trauma cover claims totalling $357,357,574
Their biggest trauma cover claim paid was for $3,218,899
For the year ended 31 March 2024, Partners Life
paid 93% of claims
paid $51,020,381 of monthly disability cover claims cost across 3,332 claims paid
paid $61,130,350 of life cover claims across 208 claims paid
paid $71,705,905 of private medical cover claims across 12,891 claims paid
paid $66,106,600 of trauma cover claims across 655 claims paid
More daily news:
ASB looks for Chief Investment Officer
BNZ survey finds 87% of New Zealanders were targeted by scams in the past 12 months
IFSO reminds kiwis to review their insurance policies
The Insurance & Financial Services Ombudsman Scheme is reminding New Zealanders to thoroughly review their insurance policies.
The Insurance & Financial Services Ombudsman (IFSO) Scheme is reminding New Zealanders to thoroughly review their insurance policies. Karen Stevens, the Insurance & Financial Services Ombudsman, has noted that some policyholders are unaware of specific limitations which can leave them without cover for something they thought was included. Stevens has cautioned kiwis of the need to familiarise themselves with their policy terms and conditions, paying particular attention to exclusions, as it is the consumer’s responsibility to understand the terms laid out in the policy.
More news:
Mark Banicevich believes new FAP regime creates opportunities for advisers
The FSC publish Life Insurance Industry Spotlight June 2024
Southern Cross Healthcare is looking for a Head of Enterprise Risk & Assurance
Rachel Wilson joins Fidelity Life as Business Manager Wellington region
Southern Cross release new online mindfulness practice available free to all New Zealanders
Southern Cross Healthcare sponsors Round the Bays fun runs, including Christchurch
The General Practice Owners Association has laid a complaint with the Commerce Commission over “unfair” and “illegal” contracts
If you have an adviser – you tend to get better claim outcomes
Jon-Paul Hale questions the use of automated portals when it comes to claims time.
Regulatory reviews in Australia have found the claims acceptance rates for the life insurance industry between distribution channels. The difference is marked – claims acceptance rates for advised retail policies was 92.1% compared to 87.8% for direct policies. For a good review check out Jack Howitt’s article here.
Jon-Paul Hale emphasises the importance of advisers at claim time, which perhaps provides an explanation for part of the gap: Hale has questioned the use of automated portals when it comes to claims time. From his experience, there are plenty of claims where, had the clients claimed through the portals without his involvement, the clients wouldn’t have had such good outcomes. He gives a range of examples and cautions that clients can forget what cover they have and how it works – all at a time when they may be feeling overwhelmed from the medical situation they are facing.
On the other hand, the difference between group and retail policies in Australia leans back the other way – more towards how the policy was underwritten as a potential cause for the difference in outcomes. Group insurance policies have some of the highest claims acceptance rates at just over 95%. Howitt’s explanation is compelling:
“This is likely due to the fact that group life insurance policies are typically underwritten on a group basis, which means that insurers have less risk associated with each individual policy. Retail advised policies may have lower claims acceptance rates due to the fact that they are typically more complex and may involve higher risk individuals. Direct policies may have lower claims acceptance rates due to the fact that insurers have less information about policyholders.”
More news:
Adviser to pay former clients compensation after he breached their privacy and caused them stress
Stats NZ report finds Māori businesses lead in employee wellbeing and flexibility
Survey finds 90% of family doctor clinics plan to increase their fees
The FSC release their latest Money & You Report
The FSC have released their latest Money & You Report, ‘Consumer Resilience and the Road to Prosperity’. It paints a picture of New Zealander’s who have struggled with the cost-of-living crisis and are feeling financially pressured to the extent they have changed their spending habits, decreased their savings and have concerns about their ongoing ability to service debt.
The FSC have released their latest Money & You Report, ‘Consumer Resilience and the Road to Prosperity’. In all it paints a picture of New Zealander’s who have struggled with the cost-of-living crisis and are feeling financially pressured to the extent they have changed their spending habits, decreased their savings and have concerns about their ongoing ability to service debt.
Some key findings include:
49% are somewhat or very unconfident in the overall economy (up from 45% in 2023), with women older generations and Europeans more likely to be unconfident in the economy. Those who are receiving financial advice are more positive about the impact of the economic climate.
94% of respondents are concerned about financial issues, with the cost of living cited as respondents’ top financial concern (66% very concerned), followed by inflation (51% very concerned) and house prices (45% very concerned).
Financial pressures have resulted in a change in spending habits, with buying cheaper groceries (57%) and cutting back on takeaways (55%) and treat purchases (49%) the most common changes. Concerningly some New Zealanders have reported skipping meals (17%), limiting heating (24%) and avoiding medical treatment or skipping medication (16%).
31% of New Zealanders were unhappy with their financial situation this year (up from 22% in 2023 and 25% in 2022).
There has been a drop in the number of retirees with more than 10 years of retirement savings, and an increase in those with less than one year of current retirement savings.
82% hold investments, with KiwiSaver the most likely held investment type.
Troubling KiwiSaver trends include average member weekly contributions dropping 7.8% (comparing 2023 to 2021); hardship withdrawals are at an all-time high; the KiwiSaver gender gap continues to increase, now sitting at a $7,450 average balance difference between males and females. Most worryingly, the average KiwiSaver member who has been contributing all their working life may not have enough to support them during retirement, according to Massey University Retirement Expenditure Guidelines.
Those who have struggled to make recent debt payments have been more proactive, with 29% reaching out to their bank (up from 20% in 2023) or speaking to family or friends (38% up from 28%).
Research was conducted via online survey, with 2,002 respondents completing the data during March 2024.
More news:
Chubb Life Chief Executive Gail Costa is to retire in April 2025
Anna Schubert talks through self-development tips for advisers
Tony Vidler suggests how advisers can create compelling offers
Clive Fernandes writes of how AI can help personalise financial advice
‘Inspiring Success’ event takes place on 7 November in Auckland
mySolutions webinar 'SimpleWills and your estate' 11 September
Debate whether it is it time to boost KiwiSaver contributions at FSC pre-conference session
Value For Money report highlights top performing ethical KiwiSaver funds
Lloyd Burr writes about how hard it is to start a new bank in NZ
Inland Revenue is proposing to make fees charged for fund management exempt from GST